For cooks comparing gotham steel air fryer reviews, this product is an oven-ready crisper set rather than a standalone countertop machine.
Its raised mesh basket and catch pan are designed to support air circulation and collect drips while using an oven’s air-fry or convection setting.
Gotham Steel Tray Review Summary
The quick verdict

13,000+ ratings
Read Amazon ReviewsGotham Steel Crisper Tray
A compact oven crisper set for cooks who want to air fry, bake, roast, or reheat without adding a countertop appliance.
- Two-piece arrangement: a raised mesh basket sits over a solid catch pan.
- Round 13.12-inch size, intended to sit on many standard oven racks and fit some small convection and air-fryer ovens.
- Gotham Steel Ti Cerama nonstick coating in a copper-colored finish on the basket and tray.
- Aluminum-core construction with titanium and ceramic nonstick materials; described as free of PTHE, PFOA, and PFOS.
Pros
- The basket-and-pan pairing gives food an elevated cooking surface while catching drips below.
- Supports several oven cooking tasks, including air frying, baking, roasting, and reheating.
Consider before buying
- At 13.12 inches across, the round set may not suit every oven cavity or rack; measuring first is important.
- It depends on a compatible oven and its settings, so it is not a self-contained air fryer.
Read the full review summary
The Gotham Steel Crisper Tray pairs a round mesh basket with a solid pan, giving food an elevated cooking surface and a tray beneath it for grease and crumbs.
Its 13.12-inch round size is intended for many standard oven racks and some compact convection and air-fryer ovens, though buyers should measure their usable space before ordering.
This set makes the most sense for someone who already cooks with an oven and wants a dedicated surface for fries, wings, vegetables, roasting, baking, or reheating.
The nonstick coating and dishwasher-safe construction aim to simplify release and cleanup. It does not replace a heating appliance, and the final fit depends on the dimensions of your oven.
The buying factors
Gotham Steel Tray Scorecard
Editorial scores reflect listed features and buyer fit; they are not laboratory measurements or customer ratings.
Oven versatility
The set is described for air frying, baking, roasting, and reheating in compatible oven settings.
Airflow-oriented design
The raised mesh basket leaves space around food for hot air circulation.
Drip management
A solid pan beneath the basket catches grease and crumbs during cooking.
Kitchen footprint
The round set can suit oven cooking without taking up the counter space of a separate appliance, subject to oven fit.
Cleanup convenience
The coated basket and pan are described as dishwasher safe for easier cleanup.
Fit flexibility
Its 13.12-inch round form is intended for many ovens, but buyers should check rack and cavity dimensions.
Key Features and Specifications of Gotham Steel Tray
- Two-piece arrangement: a raised mesh basket sits over a solid catch pan.
- Round 13.12-inch size, intended to sit on many standard oven racks and fit some small convection and air-fryer ovens.
- Gotham Steel Ti Cerama nonstick coating in a copper-colored finish on the basket and tray.
- Aluminum-core construction with titanium and ceramic nonstick materials; described as free of PTHE, PFOA, and PFOS.
- Dishwasher-safe construction for cleanup after cooking.
- Designed for oven air-fry, bake, and roast settings, with the pan collecting drips and crumbs beneath the basket.
Pros and Cons of Gotham Steel Tray
Pros
- The basket-and-pan pairing gives food an elevated cooking surface while catching drips below.
- Supports several oven cooking tasks, including air frying, baking, roasting, and reheating.
- Nonstick coating and dishwasher-safe construction are convenient for routine cleanup.
- Uses an existing compatible oven rather than requiring a separate countertop appliance.
Consider before buying
- At 13.12 inches across, the round set may not suit every oven cavity or rack; measuring first is important.
- It depends on a compatible oven and its settings, so it is not a self-contained air fryer.
- The mesh basket and catch pan add two pieces to wash and store, even when dishwasher cleanup is available.
Who Should Buy Gotham Steel Tray?
Good fit
Consider the Gotham Steel Crisper Tray if you regularly use an oven’s air-fry or convection setting and want a purpose-made basket with a pan underneath.
The raised mesh design is useful when you want air to move around food, while the lower tray gives grease and loose crumbs a place to collect instead of falling directly onto the oven rack.
It also suits cooks who would rather use existing oven equipment than make room for another countertop appliance.
The tray is described for baking, roasting, and reheating as well, so it can serve more than one role in a small kitchen.
Check the internal width and depth of your oven, plus any rack clearance, against the round 13.12-inch dimensions before choosing it.
The coating and dishwasher-safe construction may appeal if cleanup is a deciding factor.
Follow the care guidance supplied with the product, and confirm that your dishwasher has room for both pieces if you plan to clean them that way.
Who should skip it
Skip this set if you need a standalone appliance with its own heating controls; this product is an oven accessory and relies on a compatible oven.
Look elsewhere if your oven’s usable rack area is smaller than the round tray or if you need a cooking surface shaped to fit a particular model.
Measure first rather than assuming that a compact-oven fit will work for your setup.
How the Gotham Steel Tray Fits Oven Cooking
Raised mesh for oven air flow
The basket rests above the solid pan, leaving air space around food rather than placing it directly on a flat sheet.
This layout is intended to support circulation during air-fry or convection cooking; it can be a practical format for smaller pieces that benefit from an open cooking surface.
A catch pan changes cleanup
The lower pan is part of the cooking setup, not just a storage base: it catches grease and crumbs beneath the mesh.
That can help contain drips during use, though both pieces still need to be cleaned and the pan takes up oven and storage space.
Check the oven before buying
The stated round diameter is a useful starting point, but the inside width alone may not tell the whole story.
Measure the rack area and consider how the tray will move through the oven opening, especially if your convection oven has a compact interior or fixed rack positions.
A reusable surface for several tasks
Air frying is the headline use, but the set is also intended for baking, roasting, and reheating.
That range makes it more compelling for someone who will use the basket regularly; occasional air-fry cooks may prefer to compare the storage needs with how often they expect to reach for it.
Alternatives to Gotham Steel Tray
Grill Baskets alternative

700+ ratings
Read Amazon ReviewsCave Tools Vegetable Grill Basket
Choose the Gotham Steel set for oven air-fry and roasting tasks where the catch pan is useful.
Consider the Cave Tools basket if your priority is carrying small foods to and from an outdoor grill and you want a stainless-steel basket with a handle.
- The Cave Tools basket is a rectangular stainless-steel grill basket for vegetables, fruit, shrimp, fish, and meat; it is described as dishwasher safe and includes a curved handle.
- The Gotham Steel set is designed for oven cooking and pairs a mesh basket with a solid catch pan.
Grill Baskets alternative

1,000+ ratings
Read Amazon ReviewsKona Extra Large Grill Basket
The Gotham Steel set is the closer fit for indoor oven cooking and includes a separate pan to catch drips. The Kona is a better match when you need a larger basket for vegetables on an outdoor grill.
- The Kona is an extra-large outdoor grill basket measuring 14 by 13 by 4 inches, described for vegetables and for use at high grilling temperatures.
- The Gotham Steel tray is a round oven accessory sized at 13.12 inches and intended for use with compatible oven settings.
Is Gotham Steel Tray Worth It?
The Gotham Steel Crisper Tray is worth considering if you want a reusable oven basket and catch pan for air-fry, bake, roast, and reheat tasks.
Its airflow-oriented mesh, nonstick coating, and dishwasher-safe construction make the design straightforward for regular oven use.
The key buying check is fit: measure your oven’s usable rack area and opening against the 13.12-inch round tray.
If it fits and you already use an appropriate oven setting, this set offers a practical way to add an elevated cooking surface without buying another appliance.
Your review at a glance

13,000+ ratings
Read Amazon ReviewsGotham Steel Crisper Tray
A compact oven crisper set for cooks who want to air fry, bake, roast, or reheat without adding a countertop appliance.
- Two-piece arrangement: a raised mesh basket sits over a solid catch pan.
- Round 13.12-inch size, intended to sit on many standard oven racks and fit some small convection and air-fryer ovens.
- Gotham Steel Ti Cerama nonstick coating in a copper-colored finish on the basket and tray.
- Aluminum-core construction with titanium and ceramic nonstick materials; described as free of PTHE, PFOA, and PFOS.